This discussion forum is hosted by the UNM Hobbit Society at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, NM, USA. The purpose of our group is to meet and associate with others interested in Tolkien, and to learn more about the author, his written works, and his sources through discussion, guest lectures and academically oriented activities. This blog is intended to expand discussion among UNM Hobbit Society members beyond what meeting times allow.
What is the role of music or songs in The Hobbit? Does music play a different role in this work than in Tolkien's other works? Why does Tolkien include so many songs in the works? What does the music or the songs add to the story for readers?
For me, the role of music in the Hobbit has many different purposes. The first being its appeal as a children's book, including lullabies, chants, hymns, and poems that spark the imagination of a child. These songs are included more often than the chants and poems in the Lord of the Rings. Second I think the music and the songs engage the reader more, and force them out of a passive spectating position. The reader is forced to use their imagination to come up with a tune for the word on the page. Everyone's interpretation of how the song goes is different because Tolkien didn't include sheet music with these lyrics.
I think music is an important part of his developing of middle earth and showing that this world was so real it had its own songs and music and art. I think it helps the reader to relate to the characters as well. Often during difficult times characters will sing or come up with a tune to help comfort them. I think it helps the reader to think well what would I do if I were stuck in this same position out in dangerous places with the world closing in and little to no hope of escape. Why not sing and make music and take joy in the little beauties of life.
For me, the role of music in the Hobbit has many different purposes. The first being its appeal as a children's book, including lullabies, chants, hymns, and poems that spark the imagination of a child. These songs are included more often than the chants and poems in the Lord of the Rings. Second I think the music and the songs engage the reader more, and force them out of a passive spectating position. The reader is forced to use their imagination to come up with a tune for the word on the page. Everyone's interpretation of how the song goes is different because Tolkien didn't include sheet music with these lyrics.
ReplyDeleteI think music is an important part of his developing of middle earth and showing that this world was so real it had its own songs and music and art. I think it helps the reader to relate to the characters as well. Often during difficult times characters will sing or come up with a tune to help comfort them. I think it helps the reader to think well what would I do if I were stuck in this same position out in dangerous places with the world closing in and little to no hope of escape. Why not sing and make music and take joy in the little beauties of life.
ReplyDelete